Gordon Brown and cystic fibrosis, Tony Blair and MMR

Rebekah Brooks’s appearance at the Leveson inquiry on Friday has renewed attention on The Sun’s decision, under her editorship, to reveal that Gordon Brown’s son Fraser has cystic fibrosis.

It was, I felt at the time and continue to feel today, a pretty inexcusable story to publish, irrespective of how it was sourced. It’s impossible to see how disclosing details of this boy’s health could possibly have been in the public interest. It ought to have remained private — as the press has righly done on other occasions where health information about children of leading politicians has become widely known on Fleet Street.

There’s a distinction to be made here, though, with another episode I cover in The Geek Manifesto. I’m talking, of course, about the Blairs’ refusal to answer questions about whether their son Leo had had the MMR vaccine.

At first, I thought this was defensible. It was private medical information, and in principle there was no reason why the Blairs should have been obliged to reveal it. But if they were within their rights to take this decision, it’s hard to avoid the conclusion that it was irresponsible. Privacy for Fraser Brown would have had no consequences at all for public health. But the privacy claimed for Leo Blair had a devastating effect.

As Prime Minister, Tony Blair led a government that had, correctly, sought to reassure the public that there was no link between MMR and autism, following the groundless scare promoted by the discredited Andrew Wakefield and his media champions. Yet in refusing to say whether his own son had had a routine vaccination that his health ministers were telling other parents they ought to be sanctioning for their children.

It naturally invited the question of whether Blair knew something his government wasn’t sharing with ordinary parents. It suggested that the Prime Minister did not trust the advice being given by his own Health Secretary. It gave the MMR scare fresh legs in the media, which in turn caused a collapse in MMR vaccination rates and to an upsurge in measles infections.

The Prime Minister’s reticence might have been more understandable had Leo not been vaccinated. But Blair later admitted in his autobiography that his son had been given the jab.

As Michael Specter wrote on the saga in Denialism: “No virus respects privacy… so public health is never solely personal, as the impact on Britain has shown.”

About markgfh

Mark Henderson is Head of Communications at the Wellcome Trust, a global charitable foundation dedicated to achieving extraordinary improvements in human and animal health by supporting the brightest minds in biomedical research and the medical humanities. The Geek Manifesto contains his personal views, not those of the Wellcome Trust. Before joining the Trust in January 2012, Mark was Science Editor of The Times, where he built a reputation as one of Britain's foremost science journalists and commentators. Mark's first book, 50 Genetics Ideas You Really Need to Know, was published in 2009 by Quercus
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Gordon Brown and cystic fibrosis, Tony Blair and MMR

  1. And today, Monday June 11, we learn that the Browns were shocked when the story broke, that they were not consulted and would have requested privacy both for their own sake and that of the child, and that the probable source was someone within the NHS betraying a confidence.

    As for the Blairs, comment is, as usual, superfluous.

  2. jdc325 says:

    The Prime Minister’s reticence might have been more understandable had Leo not been vaccinated. But Blair later admitted in his autobiography that his son had been given the jab.

    There’s also the point that it would have been more understandable if Tony and Cherie hadn’t both written about Leo in their autobiographies – according to Ben Goldacre’s Bad Science, Cherie wrote about both Leo’s vaccination against measles and “the precise bonk that conceived Leo”. They refused to answer questions about Leo’s vaccination in the middle of an ill-founded health scare but were both quite happy to write about it in the books they were flogging.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s